Dude, it looks like the condom broke, I guess my thick, creamy load is buried deep inside your formerly tight ass… with the jizz of my friends.  I am not sure what happened, we each put on a condom like you asked, but they all broke right right before we emptied our balls into your guts.  I guess using outdated condoms, that have been stored in the trunk of my car for six years of summer heat and freezing winters might not have been the best idea.  We thought that rubbing Vaseline on our cocks first would help get the regular size condoms on our Magnum sized cocks, but I guess the warning label is right, it does “affect condom integrity“

But maybe it was just bad luck, lets have the next few guys use the same box of rubbers with Vaseline.  If their condoms break too, we will know that we should get fresh condoms for the next boy we gang bang.